Is the hole exactly 2"? Im not sure a 1.5 bulkhead would fit. The abs bulkheads from BRS require a 2.3" hole for the 1.5 bulkhead. If it's exactly 2", it sounds more like a 1.25...if they even make those.
Could also be for a 1" schedule 80 bulkhead if the hole is slightly under 2"
Double check that measurement. 1" standard bulkheads fit a 1 3/4" hole. 1" sch 80 bulkhead fits a 1.88" hole.
1.5" standard bulkhead fits a 2.32" hole.
1" schedule 80 will be the best fit assuming the hole is exactly 2". Is this a glass cages tank by any chance? (they usually drill for sch 80 bulkheads IIRC)